Greater Dayton Real Estate Investors Association Logo



                  Join Today!

How to Vet a Contractor: The Hard‑Line Guide For Investors Who Refuse to be Burned

0
Comments

Contractors can make or break an investment. And in today’s market, investors cannot afford blown timelines, disappearing crews, or budget‑destroying surprises. The safest approach is a disciplined, zero‑nonsense vetting process that protects the project, the property, and the bottom line.

This is the aggressive, cautionary framework used by investors who refuse to get burned.

🚫 1. Start With a Non‑Negotiable Rule: No Deposits

Professional contractors with stable businesses do not need large upfront payments.
Deposits create risk, reduce leverage, and reward contractors before they’ve earned trust.

Safer alternative:

• Pay nothing upfront for labor
• Pay only after work is completed and verified
• If materials are required, you purchase them directly

If a contractor insists on a deposit, treat it as a red flag and move on.

🧾 2. Buy All Materials Yourself

This eliminates:

• Markups
• Substitutions
• “Lost receipts”
• Delays caused by contractors not picking up supplies
• Disputes about what was or wasn’t included

Buying materials yourself keeps control where it belongs — with the investor.

Contractor provides labor.
Investor provides materials.
Simple, clean, and fully documented.

🔍 3. Verify Licensing, Insurance, and Legitimacy Before Anything Else

Before discussing price, availability, or scope, confirm:

• Active state contractor license
• Liability insurance
• Workers’ comp or exemption
• Business registration
• Real references
• Real job history

If any documentation is missing, expired, or “in process,” the conversation ends.

📞 4. Call References With Zero Hesitation

Do not rely on online reviews or vague testimonials.

Ask references:

• Did the contractor finish on time
• Did the final price match the estimate
• Were there surprise add‑ons
• Did communication stay consistent
• Would they hire the contractor again

If references hesitate, pause, or give lukewarm answers, treat it as a warning.

🧱 5. Inspect Past Work — Not Just Photos

Photos can be staged.
Job sites cannot.

Look for:

• Clean, organized work areas
• Consistent finishes
• Straight lines, tight corners, clean caulk
• Professional behavior on site

If the contractor refuses a walkthrough of a current or recent job, stop the process.

🧩 6. Demand a Detailed Written Scope of Work

A vague scope is the fastest path to blown budgets.

A proper SOW includes:

• Exact materials (brand, SKU, color, finish)
• Labor details
• Cleanup expectations
• Timeline with milestones
• Payment schedule tied to completed work
• Change order process

If it’s not in writing, it doesn’t exist.

💬 7. Evaluate Communication With Zero Emotion

Communication problems during the estimate phase will become disasters during the project.

Watch for:

• Slow responses
• Vague answers
• Excuses
• Unclear pricing
• Resistance to written communication

Professional contractors communicate professionally.
Everyone else creates risk.

🧭 8. Start With a Small Test Job

Never hand a contractor a full rehab without testing them first.

A small project reveals:

• Reliability
• Work quality
• Speed
• Professionalism
• Respect for your systems

If they fail a small job, they will fail a big one.

🚩 9. Treat Red Flags as Stop Signs

Walk away immediately if you see:

• Cash‑only requests
• No written contract
• No insurance
• Pressure to start immediately
• Large upfront payment demands
• Inconsistent stories
• Vague pricing
• Unwillingness to follow your SOW

Red flags do not improve with time.

🏆 10. Maintain a Bench of Contractors

Never rely on one contractor.
A strong bench gives investors:

• Leverage
• Options
• Protection
• Continuity

Contractors perform better when they know they are not the only option.

Final Thoughts

Contractor problems are not bad luck — they are the result of weak vetting.
Investors who follow a strict, emotion‑free process avoid the disasters that wipe out profits.

No deposits.
You buy the materials.
Everything in writing.
No exceptions.



Tags



Be the First to Comment: